Norse and Aztecs · 1408
Were the Greenland Norse victims of the Little Ice Age?
The seminar question: “To what extent were the Greenland Norse victims of the Little Ice Age?”
From about 1275–1300 the Little Ice Age brought drift ice along Greenland’s coasts and drier summers that cut the hay for cattle. The Norse adapted by eating far more seal, but the ivory market weakened, the Black Death struck Norway in 1349 and ships came less often; the Western Settlement was empty by about 1360.
Chapter 5 is included with every paid plan. WW2 is free in full, and chapter 1 of every atlas is free. A free account opens 3 more chapters a day. Starter, at $9 a month, opens all 21 with no daily limit — see the plans.
Free printable Norse and Aztecs study guide, sent by email ↓

A change in diet gives us a way to see the Norse response to cold. Isotopes are chemical signatures in bone that indicate whether a person’s dietary protein came from land or sea. Jette Arneborg’s team estimated that marine food supplied about 20 percent at settlement and about 80 percent near the end. A later study of 123 skeletons placed the early share between 15 and 50 percent and found that it passed 50 percent in the late thirteenth century.
The short answer
- Cooler and drier summers cut the hay. Gifford Miller’s team dates the abrupt beginning of the Little Ice Age to about 1275–1300 and another intensification to 1430–1455. At Lake 578 in south Greenland, the clearer signal is drying rather than cooling. This mattered to farmers because cattle needed stored hay for eight months. Several bad summers could force a cull; rebuilding the herd would take years, leaving less in reserve when the next poor harvest came.
- Drift ice lengthened and endangered voyages. A voyage from Iceland or Norway became longer and more dangerous as summer drift ice spread along eastern and southern Greenland. A late-medieval sailing guide says the old route was abandoned because of ice, although that sentence may be a later addition. With fewer ships came less iron, timber and grain, less news, and fewer opportunities for people to leave or new settlers to arrive. The colony had less contact through which to address its other problems.
- The ivory economy weakened. Greenland used walrus ivory to pay for imports. The trade could still be valuable: about 520 tusks sent as church dues in 1327 were worth roughly 780 cows. But hunters later sought smaller animals farther away, and European buyers were again obtaining elephant ivory from Africa. Greenland was relying on a product that was becoming harder to secure while its market was changing.
- Plague and isolation in Norway. Norway’s own crisis weakened its connection with Greenland. The Black Death arrived in 1349 and killed perhaps half or more of the population, reducing the market and shipping. Bergen merchants turned to the profitable dried-cod trade; after the royal Greenland ship sank in 1369, it was not replaced. Thinner contact made iron and timber harder to obtain, and worn iron tools could not be replaced without trade.
THE TURNING POINT
Hvalsey church, 16 September 1408. Þorsteinn Ólafsson and Sigríður Björnsdóttir married in Hvalsey’s stone church on 16 September 1408. Their record survived because they later needed proof of the marriage in Iceland. It is the last written evidence from Norse Greenland, and it shows a community still maintaining a church, priests and legal documents. Within roughly a generation the remaining evidence is archaeological. The ordinary wedding followed by silence fits the question historians now ask about departure as well as catastrophe.
What it changed
Greenland becomes Inuit land. By about 1500 Inuit communities occupied much of Greenland’s west and south coasts, including the former Norse districts. The map’s blue zones trace their movement south. Their descendants make up most of Greenland’s population today. The Norse settlements had given way to a society equipped to live in Arctic conditions.
A debate that shaped modern environmental history. Norse Greenland became a famous example in arguments about climate and collapse, especially through Jared Diamond’s 2005 book. Archaeological responses have emphasized adaptation under several converging pressures. That approach also helps frame the Mexica case later in this atlas, where a lake city faced flood, frost and drought.
Europe forgets and then searches. Norway lost contact with Greenland in the fifteenth century, and Europeans gradually forgot where the colony lay. Danish and Norwegian rulers later renewed the search, sometimes expecting to find Norse descendants. Voyages from the sixteenth to the eighteenth centuries eventually led to Danish colonization from 1721, discussed in the epilogue. The Skálholt map, drawn in Iceland around 1570, shows geography preserved through written memory.
The full answer, argued
The Little Ice Age made life harder, but it did not act alone. Cooling and drying narrowed the margin for producing hay, and drift ice made voyages more difficult. The Norse responded by obtaining much of their food from the sea, especially seals; Inuit expansion in the same centuries shows that people using different technology could live in Greenland. At the same time, weaker ivory trade, plague in Norway and the loss of regular shipping reduced the income and contact on which the colony depended. Following Dugmore and colleagues, most scholars describe a convergence of pressures on a community too small to absorb them all. Evidence for orderly farm departures suggests that many people chose to leave. Climate could work slowly, narrowing alternatives until departure became sensible.
An interesting fact
In 1921 Poul Nørlund excavated the churchyard at Herjólfsnes, where permafrost had preserved woolen gowns, hoods and caps. One tall cap resembled fashion at the fifteenth-century Burgundian court and was taken as evidence that Greenlanders followed European fashion after 1500. Radiocarbon dating placed it instead around 1280–1380, about two centuries earlier than that interpretation suggested. Other grave clothes from the churchyard date to about 1430, the latest firm evidence of Norse people in Greenland.
This is the study layer of Why the Norse abandoned Greenland, chapter 5 of Climate and Innovation: The Norse and the Aztecs, c. 790–1521; the full index of the atlas is here.
Related questions
THE FREE PRINTABLE STUDY GUIDE
Get the printable study guide for Climate and Innovation free. I’ll send you a few short letters, then one when a new atlas opens. That’s all. — Paul
NO TRACKING · YOUR ADDRESS IS USED FOR THE DISPATCH AND NOTHING ELSE · UNSUBSCRIBE ANYTIME